Casey M. Martin is the head
men’s golf coach at the University of Oregon. Martin also suffers
from Klippel-Trenaunay syndrome, a congenital disorder which has made
his right leg weaker, thinner and painful to stand on. Martin famously
was denied access to a golf cart in order to compete in the PGA Tour in
2000. Later, in 2001, the Supreme Court ruled in his favor, citing the
Americans with Disabilities Act.
1) The issue of accessibility in
sports is becoming more visible. What do you see as the trend, and how
did your experience with the PGA Tour speak to the issue?
I was pretty involved [in the issue]—I followed it pretty closely
based upon my ordeal. I think it goes back to the [infrequency] of
playing sports at the highest level without being 100 percent
physically able. I don’t think accommodation for athletes with
disabilities is going to be a major trend in athletics, just because
it’s so difficult to get to that level. There will be unique
situations that come up every so often. Mine was one, and I’m
sure there will be more, but they will not be the norm, in my opinion.
[The PGA Tour] didn’t want to have two separate rules. They
didn’t want to have to make exceptions, because they felt it
would just be opening up a Pandora’s box of every ache and pain a
player would want accommodation for.
We showed them my leg and did everything we could to let them know what
I was dealing with, and they weren’t willing to budge.
Fortunately, the [Supreme Court] saw things differently, because the
law says you have to make individual assessments for people. I think
the [PGA Tour’s] reasoning [was], “We just have one set of
rules and you [have] to abide by it.” It makes sense, but when
there’s a thing called the ADA [Americans with Disabilities Act],
you have to take that into account too.
2) Is having separate athletic contests discriminatory or encouraging?
If they weren’t separate, if there was just the Olympics and no
Paralympics, [disabled] people wouldn’t have a place to compete
at all, because those people aren’t going to be at the highest
level. I don’t think [separate contests are] discriminatory, I
think it’s good that people with physical limitations are at
least given a chance to compete and become as good as they can be in
their respective sports.
My wish is that the special ones who can really compete at the highest
level would get those opportunities [to compete with able-bodied
athletes]. But it does become a judgment call, I guess.
3) Do you think Oscar Pistorius should have been allowed to compete with able-bodied sprinters?
It’s hard to say, because I’m not an expert on those
things, and if the scientist thinks his legs are bionic, obviously
that’s a problem. But I don’t think there’s one
runner in the world that would choose to give up his legs to have the
Cheetah blade. So I don’t think it’s accurate [to] say the
guy has an advantage over an able-bodied athlete. It would seem to me a
stretch to say that.
4) As a coach, how do you help players overcome injuries or limitations of their own?
[In] golf, we don’t have too many injuries. We had a boy sprain
his ankle playing basketball, but nothing that really requires
accommodation.
There could easily be a situation. I know some golfers really struggle
with their backs and need a pull-cart versus carrying their bag,
[although] the rules say you have to carry a bag. The motion of golf
can be very bad on backs, especially if you injure it early on. Then
the repetitive motion of swinging can really affect your back.
5) What do you love most about playing golf?
I love the game, I love the challenge of trying to create shots and hit
them, and I love the competition of trying to go out there and beat the
next guy. That has always been fun for me, since [I was] a kid. Now,
even though I’m not playing as much, [what] I enjoy as a coach is
trying to get the best team and make [it] better and compete, and the
thrill of all that.
Interview by Heather Benjamin, assistant editor of the O&P Almanac.